Focus on: Energy Management
By Sam Khalilieh
Study after study has concluded that adding doors to medium temperature coolers (MTC) is a great solution for a variety of issues that plague retailers. Whether looking at energy use, operational costs, product safety or consumer comfort, there is no downside to adding doors. So why do so many overlook this very basic approach?
Supermarkets have some of the most operationally complex and expensive building systems of all retailers. U.S. grocery retailers spend an average of $4.10 on electricity and 26 cents on natural gas per square foot annually. As much as 60% of the $4.10 goes toward refrigeration alone. Energy costs, especially those related to refrigeration, take a chunk out of their profits! (Consider this: Since energy expenditure is the same as profit margin for a typical grocery store — about 1% to 2% — a 10% reduction in energy cost can boost profit margins by as much as 6% to 7%!)
An open display case consumes about 30% more energy than a doored display case. But everyone continues to value-engineer their refrigeration systems and reduce their refrigerant charge, leaks and carbon footprint, as they neglect a pretty basic solution to the problem.
The industry has dithered about adding doors to dairy, beer, lunch meat and bagged salad and other medium temperature coolers for years. Some say that open cases are necessary to convey the “fresh” concept. However, most shoppers know that the first item in the case is never as cold or fresh as the one behind it, and you often see shoppers choosing an item from farther back in the case. With a doored cooler, shoppers feel completely comfortable grabbing the first item.
Another argument says that adding doors negatively impacts sales. Here, there are plenty of retailers that have experimented with doors, as well as quantitative research that supports making the change to doored coolers. Indeed, some grocery chains are adding doors to all their MTC in all their new stores and are also retrofitting existing one to add doors to their MTCs. An ASHRAE study entitled “Comparison of Vertical Display Cases: Energy and Productivity Impacts of Glass Doors Versus Open Vertical Display Cases” found that replacing an open refrigerated case lineup with a doored case lineup did not appear to negatively affect sales.
Doored cases also eliminate one of the biggest shopper turnoffs in supermarkets — freezing cold aisles created by cold air spillage from the cases. It’s common sense that shoppers spend more time shopping the aisle when they are comfortable, and the longer they spend shopping the aisle, the more they buy.
Another ASHRAE study, “Supermarkets, Indoor Climate and Energy Efficiency —Field Measurements Before and After Installation of Doors on Refrigerated Cases,” analyzed the impact of doors on the customer experience in the supermarket. Customers found the store environment to be more comfortable after the doors were installed. The study also notes that doored cases improve food safety by reducing large variations in product temperatures that can be found in open cases.
The idea of adding doors on MTCs may or may not be applicable to every product and every store. With the proper door selection (using a minimal frame), LED lighting, electronically commutated motors (ECM), tax incentives, the right product behind these doors and the proper messaging to consumers, it is a win-win for everyone. And for those retailers pursuing LEED certification, they will be handsomely rewarded with LEED points. But most importantly, they will be able to back up their sustainability message with actions that truly make a difference.
Sam Khalilieh, PE, LEED AP, is senior VP architecture and engineering, WD Partners, Dublin, Ohio.